tonytalkssports My Take on Sports, particularly the Yankees, Maple Leafs and Browns

Mistakes Galore: Leafs Lose 3-1

The Toronto Maple Leafs played one of their worst games of the season dropping a 3-1 decision to the Carolina Hurricanes. The Leafs saw their road record fall to 6-2 as their defensive play reminded me of times last season when the wheels fell off. Bad pinches by defensemen, lack of a forecheck and an inability to get out of their own end marked most of the night in Raleigh for the Blue & White.

Ben Scrivens, filling in for the injured James Reimer, was solid but made a bad decision in trying to unsuccessfully cover a puck which resulted in the winning goal for the Hurricanes. Scrivens gave the Leafs an opportunity to come back in the third period as he made several key saves. But Toronto was unable to generate any offense as Carolina continued its winning ways.

John-Michael Liles had one of his worst games as a Maple Leaf and I have to wonder if he might not be a player that the Leafs could move before the April 3rd trade deadline. Liles has not provided much offensive punch from the blue line and is not overly physical. His brutal pinch when Clarke MacArthur turned over the puck led to a 3 on 1 break which resulted in the third goal for the Hurricanes. What was even more disturbing was the fact that Scrivens made the first save but no Leaf was around to pick up the other Carolina players. That play specifically reminded me of the Ron Wilson coached teams.

MacArthur is one of a few forwards who really needs to step up their game. He really has not been a consistent contributor offensively. I have been a defender of Nikolai Kulemin but I'm beginning to wonder if we may have seen his best season 2 years ago when he scored 29 goals. He appears to be totally out of it offensively and should not be getting the amount of power play time that he does. Mikhail Grabovski is also slumping offensively and without his scoring really puts the Leafs in a deep hole.

The Leafs first line was nearly invisible last night. What was clear is that the Bozak line can't compare to the Eric Staal line. Once again, Staal was a threat all night and Alexander Semin seems to have have been rejuvenated playing alongside the big center man. If you want to see the importance of a big center all you had to do was watch Staal last night.

It's not time to give up on the Leafs, after all they were not going to win the rest of their games. What was upsetting was not the loss but was the lack of effort. Saturday's game against Ottawa will be very telling as to how the rest of this season will unfold. If the Leafs play hard and provide the effort which was evident in their four game winning streak, then it would be evidence that Coach Randy Carlyle's system has taken hold. But if the Senators take it to the Leafs at the ACC, it might be time to begin to wonder if GM Dave Nonis may be willing to move some players before the trade deadline in April. In my mind, effort will be what I will be looking for on Saturday night at the Air Canada Centre. A spirited game at home against their provincial rival is what we should expect. Anything less will be cause for concern in this shortened season.